The above thoughts about why my win rate is not as high as I think it should be has had me thinking alot about this over the last hour or so and I am going to try and come up with some explanation.
In B&M I think a good average of hands per hour is probably in the neighborhood of 35-40 with good dealers and online at the lower limits I have done some looking around and it seems like 55 hands per hour is a pretty sound number to start at there, probably a little higher at higher limits but at the lower limits with more players in per pot I think a little less than a hand per minute is pretty close. So in my estimate previously I was doubling what I thought I should be making at each table because of the double amount of hands per hour and this just isn't accurate (although if I had a few more dealers like the ones in Baton Rouge on the riverboats it would be very close
)
So if I use 35 hands per hour versus 55 hands per hour online as a baseline my earnings should go up to ca. 14.40 per hour per table assuming I am making 1.5 BB per hour.
Now I am also going to estimate that I increase my VIP% to about 17-20% say in live games versus my 11.21% online. I would be involved in about 4.76-5.6 hands per hour in the B&M games and 4.92 hands per hour online both removing the hands in the blinds of 7 and 11 respectively.
So I am beginning to see where all of my extra profits are going. If for the sake of argument the number of hands that I play per hour is exactly the same in both B&M and online which it very well could be or extremely close then my average per table at 36 online could very well be in the 9.00/hour range which should put me up to about 45.00.hr for 5 tables which I am not obtaining either which could also be an artifact of loss of information while multitabling as well as loss of information from physical tells. I feel a bit better now that I have actually sat down and explained away were alot of my supposed earnings are actually located and it is largely do to the fact that the number of hands I am actually playing online per table is actually pretty close to the number of hands I would be playing live per table. So perhaps my 33.15/hr at 36 isn't as bad as I first thought.
If some other folks are well above this average I would be interested to know some of your stats as far as VIP and such as I may well adjust my game a little but for right now I think I will not tinker too much from my ultraconservative methods.
Hope this has helped some others as to where your possible extra perceived profits are going if your B&M verus online game philosophy mirrors mine as far as the different styles played in the two, mainly tightening up to limit trouble situations largely due to the loss of information from physical tells. Good luck.