by Gishaclaus » Mon Dec 20, 2004 12:14 pm
Let me try to address everyone's points here; but first let me add a key point that I neglected to include. I pointed out that much of his stack came from flopping monster hands on relatively innocent boards (a full house with TT3 on the flop comes to mind). What I failed to point out is that, almost without fail, he would check call to the river and then put in a modest value raise. He never led into anyone when he flopped a hand, at least not that I could see. Anyway . . . in general, I think that folding this hand is incredibly weak.
MD --
I think the range of hands you are putting him on is incredibly compressed. You don't think he makes this play with JT? Or QT? You don't think he could put me on AK/AQ and think I missed the flop completely? Don't you think it's cheaper for him to raise now to find out where he stands? Especially since, if he is ahead, any card higher than a ten on the turn has the potential to either kill any future action or beat him outright? I know TPMK isn't a big pot kind of hand (for me anyway) but for me that was within the realm of possiblity. If the turn blanks, and then he fires out again, I would very likely fold. It would definitely depend on my read at the time.
Iceman and Felonius --
I'm amused that you think I'd be willing to back this hand with my stack. Do you think I got my big stack at this table by accident? I would be willing (and did) call his raise to see what would happen on the turn. Any aggression from him and I would fold, without hesitation. At the time, his flop raise felt too much like a move from someone who felt like I missed a flop with AK/AQ, or someone who felt I had an overpair and would lay down to a representation of a set.
So, I ended up calling after going in the tank for about a minute. Turn blanks, and he checks immediately. Your action?