<--Bows to Growlers (as usual
Hind sight being what it was, I figured I should have bet the turn (although I think I ended up getting the same amount of bets...He check/calls the turn, then check/calls the river (= 2 BB) or he bets the river and makes a cryign call to my raise (= 2BB). The more I think about it, I'm not sure he would have check/called the river had I bet out on the turn. At that point he may not have put me on a FD, but he probably could have put me on a Overpair giving the PF and Flop action...
Obviously, this is one of those hands that I've been replaying in my mind to the point that I've tried to put myself in his place. I would have check/called (IF I had been him) the turn, but once I didn't hit my str8 on the river, I'd be hard pressed to call a bet on the river.
We know that pot odds dictate that you call that bet because you're getting better then 10:1 pot odds, but not everybody has read SSHE and so most people (In my experience) will fold to a river bet if they don't hit their draw.
Now, the arguement can be had that I have absolutely no idea how many people pair their hand but miss their draw and still fold to the river bet with that large of a pot...and you are correct. However, I have to put myself in his place, and on the river, before I was familiar with pot odds to call for a potential bluff... I fold his hand.
I will say that when I was in the hand, I had to possiblitiles for the river after checking the turn...I don't hit and he bets into me (I make a crying call to ward off bluff chances (I would have lost this hand) or I hit and I induced a bluff and he folds to the river bet (showing the table I can't be bluffed off a hand or I play my strong hand agressively...either image works for me). I really didn't expect him to bet into me with the 8 hitting...it seemed like such a safe card to him (giving me the flush I wasn't even worried about trips, although I wish he would have had them
.
So, the question remains, given that the number of bets I collected was equal to a check/call-check/call from him or a check/check-bet/raise/call...what was the better play?