Interesting thread, even if it was started as a whine.
(Nice first post, Mr. Leaf. Welcome aboard.)
My answer, for which I'm absolutely positive of my opinion, is...I don't know. There as as many possible answers as there are people, I think. Limit may be dead to some because they aren't very good at it, or they find it boring, or they aren't smart enough to know what they know and don't know. I don't know, either.
What I do know is if limit is dead, why is it so hard to get on a table? Couple days ago there was a 10 person waiting list on TGC for the $1/$2 tables. I cleared $40 in bonus, and won an additional 200, in about 3 hours. Yeah, that was an exceptionally good day, but only about twice as good as usual for me (when I get decent cards). So, I guess even a mediocre player such as myself can make a bit of ching from playing limit. This may end that area of disagreement, at least from my end.
But I think it may be easier to win at limit than NL, and will continue to be for much, much longer. Praise the Lord for ESPN. It brings in a new school of fish every year. They are gutted very quickly on the NL tables, but they like the game, so they find the limit tables. They are gutted just the same, but they bleed out so slowly they don't realize they are dead until their stake hits 0. They play the same way they see "the pros on ESPN" play. Then, if they really want to keep playing, they may buy a book. Anyone who has really learned from reading poker books knows that one read through isn't going to make them a winner. Nor will two or three times through. If the book isn't dog-eared, pages taped back into the binder, page after page underlined and highlighted, and the reader is able to quote entire passages like the rosary, they still will find more to learn. As said above by a wise poker player, it's about experience, which always costs dearly. Either you pay for it with money, or with time and dedication. Whichever, you will pay or you will lose. If you're willing to pay the price, you'll reap from those unwilling to work at it, but ever so willing to pay you for your hard work.
That's what makes Texas Hold 'Em the greatest card game ever invented. So very easy to learn the rules; so very, very hard to learn the game. It seems so easy, Ma, so why am I still losing???
Because it just ain't easy, Sparky!!!
It always will be thus. The lottery is easy, but unbeatable. Yet people still play it every day. They bet the dogs and ponies. The bet the Super Bowl. People love "easy money" and they see all the money that is being won in Vegas on ESPN and how easy it is and they will keep playing. THE is the game of now and always. Anytime, anywhere on any site, there is a limit table with 10 players, 2 at most are really good, four are calling stations, 2 are maniacs on their way to broke, and 2 are clueless. If there are 2 at your table that are really good, let them win their share. (See sig below.) You split up the rest between you. If you're one of the good ones.
It's easy to know. What's in YOUR wallet?
Good thread.
CJ
"Are the players better as the stakes go up? It's not an exam; it's a buyin." Barry Tanenbaum