Well, it turned out UTG+1 made a really weird play when he showed
[9c]. BB showed
[2d]. This goes to show that you can't trust PokerOffice too much I guess. Just because someone is rated TAG over 40+ hands, doesn't mean he knows how to play. Or maybe he's on tilt. Or maybe he's an exceptionally card-dead LAG.
You made a really good analysis as always, EP9, in pointing out some stuff that I had missed.