by k3nt » Tue Dec 04, 2007 2:34 pm
JC, I mentioned before that is a raised and reraised pot at 6-max. The pot going to the flop in that thread is 33 BBs. Here, I'm instructed to flat call preflop so that the pot going to the flop is 8 BBs. I don't think the earlier thread applies at all to this situation.
To be more specific: Aisthesis' very extensive discussion in that thread requires us to checkraise all-in on a rag flop. I don't think that's an option here. Aisthesis' reasoning in support of it presumes that there would be a very big pot that we would take from AK, to make up for the fact that we will lose our stack vs AA/KK. That simply doesn't apply to this case.
On a Jxx flop, Aisthesis says (again in the other thread) we should bet out and fold to a raise. That makes sense when the pot is enormous and our bet appears to make us pot committed, so that someone would need balls of steel to push in with AK or TT. But in a smaller pot like the one I'm talking about, a decent % of people will raise headsup when led into with a very wide range. Ice says that's a good play, and in my experience he's right. So bet out and fold to a raise stinks in this situation ... doesn't it?
The more I think about it, the more I hate a flat call out of position preflop. We're effectively trapping with what may or may not be the best hand, and our hand is vulnerable to a bunch of cards even when it is best right now ... and we'll be out of position the rest of the way. I'd rather have 22 and play set or forget than try to play the guessing game of "is my QQ good on this board?" out of position.