This is a discussion I'm having on another forum. I'm in big disagreement with another poster over how third street should have been played here. Anybody care to weigh in?

HERO believes he made his first big mistake on 4th. I believe 3rd was where he messed up.

*** 3rd STREET ***
Dealt to GOCUBSGO
Dealt to Jackson35
Dealt to melmet
Dealt to HERO [8h Js Jd]
Dealt to dayn_1
Dealt to quadandhamm0
Dealt to erfigo
dayn_1: brings-in low $2
quadandhamm0: folds
erfigo: calls $2
Wakeupdog joins the table at seat #6
GOCUBSGO: calls $2
Jackson35: calls $2
melmet: calls $2
HERO: calls $2
*** 4th STREET ***
Dealt to GOCUBSGO
Dealt to Jackson35
Dealt to melmet
Dealt to HERO [8h Js Jd]
Dealt to dayn_1
Dealt to erfigo
dayn_1: checks
erfigo: checks
GOCUBSGO: checks
Jackson35: checks
melmet: checks
HERO: bets $5
dayn_1: folds
erfigo: calls $5
GOCUBSGO: calls $5
Jackson35: calls $5
melmet: calls $5
*** 5th STREET ***
Dealt to GOCUBSGO [Qs 2d]
Dealt to Jackson35 [5c Tc]
Dealt to melmet [9h Td]
Dealt to HERO [8h Js Jd 2c]
Dealt to erfigo [5d Kd]
Jackson35: bets $10
melmet: calls $10
HERO: calls $10
erfigo: folds
GOCUBSGO: calls $10
*** 6th STREET ***
Dealt to GOCUBSGO [Qs 2d 9s]
Dealt to Jackson35 [5c Tc 5h]
Dealt to melmet [9h Td 8s]
Dealt to HERO [8h Js Jd 2c 8c]
Jackson35: checks
melmet: checks
HERO: bets $10
GOCUBSGO: calls $10
Jackson35: folds
melmet: calls $10
*** RIVER ***
Dealt to HERO [8h Js Jd 2c 8c 7s]
GOCUBSGO: checks
melmet: checks
HERO: checks
*** SHOW DOWN ***
GOCUBSGO: shows [Kh Kc Qs 2d 9s 3c 3h] (two pair, Kings and Threes)
melmet: mucks hand
HERO: mucks hand

JJ seems vulnerable, so i'd raise on 3rd. but that's purely from a theoretical armchair analysis. you know i don't play stud.

raise or not, i don't think the result would be much different. he still loses to kings up.

i look forward to reading your line.