Party Poker No-Limit Hold'em, $ BB (10 handed) from (Format: FlopTurnRiver)

saw flop|saw showdown

CO ($19.50)
Button ($6.20)
SB ($54.95) VPIP 45, PFR% 9
BB ($38.44)
UTG ($49.44)
UTG+1 ($58.38)
UTG+2 ($12.59)
MP1 ($49.50) No Hand History
Hero ($56.95)
MP3 ($47.10)

Preflop: Hero is MP2 with A, A. SB posts a blind of $0.25.
3 folds, MP1 calls $0.50, Hero raises to $2.5, 3 folds, SB (poster) raises to $4.25, 1 fold, MP1 calls $4, Hero calls $54.45 (All-In), SB folds, MP1 folds.
What do you do in this situation? I was thinking about smooth calling but I think playing the hand on the flop becomes very tricky if a queen or jack falls because one of the players could have easily made a set. I thought SB might raise with KK so he would call an all in bet. What is your move in this situation?

Final Pot: $66.45

Since you have position I wouldnt be against a smooth call. It gives you good hand deception. On a rag flop, you can get SBs stack if he has an overpair. The MP1 looks alot like a small-Med PP. So if he gets crazy at all on the flop it means set so fold. If a J/Q flops and SB gives heavy action that is a tough spot because it could be a set or just overpair QQ/KK (or TP w/AQ).

Safer way to play...
Raise to $15.00 because the all-in is a little excessive. This might bait in a weak player to call with AK or QQ-JJ type hands. And then potential go broke on a rag flop or A or K hi ones with AK.

You gotta raise to shut MP1 outta the pot. You dont wanna get stacked by 22. But no reason to go all in. I would raise to 12, denying setminers odds and easily getting calls from AK, QQ or JJ.