Poker Room skin
No Limit Holdem Ring game
Blinds: $0.25/$0.50
9 players


Stack sizes:
UTG: $48.50
UTG+1: $50.80
MP1: $60.50
MP2: $62.45
MP3: $49.50
CO: $21.35
Button: $51.25
SB: $29.45
Hero: $61.05

Pre-flop: (9 players) Hero is BB with
2 folds, MP1 calls $0.5 (pot was $0.75), 3 folds, Button calls $0.5 (pot was $1.25), SB calls $0.25 (pot was $1.75), Hero raises to $2.5, MP1 calls $2.5 (pot was $3.5), 2 folds.

Flop: ($6, 2 players)
Hero bets $7, MP1 calls $7 (pot was $13).

Turn: ($20, 2 players)
Hero bets $15, MP1 calls $15 (pot was $35).

River: ($50, 2 players)
Hero bets $20, MP1 raises all-in $35.5, Hero folds.
Uncalled bets: $15.5 returned to MP1.

Results:
Final pot: $90

My impressions in hindsight: MP1 (over 16 hands) is 19/0/2.50 (AF is misleading since river AF is infinity, not 0). I probably could've full pot the flop instead of ~1/2 potting. However, his smooth call could mean trouble regardless. What am I giving legitmate odds to draw there, asking him to call $7 to win $20? (2.86-to-1) With such a coordinated board also, I have an overpair and a gutshot, but that may not be clean if he's calling with QJ.

The turn card is a blank. I bet $15 into a $20 pot and he smooth calls. At this point, it smells like a set, but if he has a set, I still have 6 good outs (4 T's and 2 J's), Could he really have TJ here?

The river card completes the flush draw, and I launch $20 (mistake?) into a $50 pot. In hindsight, the river bet showed weakness, and he pushed. I thought--what hand that would've potentially called all the prior action does my JJ beat here? A set? No. JT? No. A poorly played flush draw? No. AK? No. QK? No. KJ? No. Should I have pushed into the 3-flush on board? As I saw it, I was behind every reasonable holding except a stone cold bluff.

I pissed away $45 on a hand that I may have been miles behind on. Opponent left after the hand, but not before he ripped into me for not calling the last $15.50 into a $105.50 pot and telling me that he only had Q-high. Could AQ really have called all that, or was he just bullshitting to attempt to tilt me?

Ideas, folks?