by Aisthesis » Fri Jan 05, 2007 3:11 am
Yeah, I haven't really read through McEvoy/Cloutier, but browsing it at the bookstore, I think it's acceptable as short (and quickly, easily read) intro. I agree with Kuso that it's good for learning to play tight--same can be said of Phil Hellmuth's chapter on the subject, too.
Monk touches on all of the more in-depth books that I know of. I'd just change the order a bit. I really feel like Rolf is actually the most advanced book and deals largely with topics that are very different from what Ciaffone and Reuben deal with.
I think the main problems with Reuben (other than the somewhat dubious quiz structure) are that he's playing in a game of regulars and that the stacks are typically WAY deep. So, some of the ideas aren't completely applicable in normal games.
I think the deep stacks mean that you can often play somewhat looser PF, particularly with position.