Only calling CR with nut flush = weak tight?

[Kuso]

I hit the nut flush on the river, value bet, and then get check-raised with a str8 flush possible. What should I do -- call or reraise?

The raiser has been a big winner at the table so far, but I only had a very limited number of hands in my pto db (around 40). It was obvious that he was aggressive pf and post flop and so far was a big winner.


***** Hand History *****
$25 PL Omaha Hi/Lo

Seat 5 is the button
Total number of players : 10
Seat 2: lambchopFTR ( $0 )
Seat 3: skippnrox ( $33.55 )
Seat 8: REKOP ( $70.57 )
Seat 9: DrCream ( $43.41 )
Seat 10: smallee ( $89.62 )
Seat 7: vegPoker28 ( $12.47 )
Seat 1: Hero ( $28.02 )
Seat 5: ROHOROHO64 ( $8.30 )
Seat 6: chemac ( $23.90 )
Seat 4: badabing50 ( $25 )
chemac posts small blind [$0.10].
vegPoker28 posts big blind [$0.25].
badabing50 posts big blind [$0.25].
** Dealing down cards **
Dealt to Hero [ Kc Th As 2s ]
lambchopFTR has left the table.
REKOP folds.
DrCream calls [$0.25].
smallee calls [$0.25].
drrew has joined the table.
Hero calls [$0.25].
skippnrox folds.
badabing50 checks.
ROHOROHO64 folds.
chemac folds.
vegPoker28 checks.
** Dealing Flop ** [ Ts, 8s, Jc ]
vegPoker28 checks.
DrCream checks.
smallee bets [$0.25].
Hero calls [$0.25].
badabing50 calls [$0.25].
vegPoker28 folds.
DrCream calls [$0.25].
** Dealing Turn ** [ 4c ]
DrCream checks.
smallee bets [$1].
Hero calls [$1].
badabing50 calls [$1].
DrCream calls [$1].
** Dealing River ** [ 9s ]
DrCream checks.
smallee checks.
Hero bets [$2].
badabing50 folds.
DrCream folds.
smallee raises [$12.05].
Hero calls [$10.05].
smallee shows [ Qh, 7s, Tc, Qs ] a flush, queen high.
Hero shows [ Kc, Th, As, 2s ] a flush, ace high.
Hero wins $28.95 from the main pot with a flush, ace high with ace kicker.
There was no qualifying low hand.


One leak in my game that I have not given enough respect to suspicious "plays" from winning players. I have been quartered quite a few times in big pots by not respecting raises and reraises from winning players (e.g., I jam with a wheel and get quartered with a 6-high str8). I am wondering if maybe I gave a bit too much respect here.

Of course, if this guy is a donk, I jam. I am willing to pay off donks on their monsters because more often than not they don't actually have it.

Your thoughts?

[Felonius_Monk]

[Kuso]

[Felonius_Monk]

No, I'd rely on my read of the player. Mostly without info I still think I'd raise it up, you get idiots at higher levels too. Against a "known" good player, though, I think I'd be calling.

It also depends on the stacks - if one raise puts you all in, it's probably correct against a majority of opponents. If both of you are deep, i.e. if you raiser there's still enough money for him to make a re-re-raise, you should be much more inclined to just call it.

[GooperMC]