Muppet move or advanced play...

[Stoneburg]

Dealt to Hero
boccirock calls [$0.50].
Calvin494949 calls [$0.50].
MrMiggle calls [$0.50].
BigSach12 calls [$0.50].
Oldweasel calls [$0.50].
Hero calls [$0.50].
sixn8 folds.
M_ace folds.
baretailed checks.

** Dealing Flop **
baretailed checks.
boccirock checks.
Calvin494949 checks.
MrMiggle checks.
BigSach12 bets [$0.50].
Oldweasel calls [$0.50].
Hero calls [$0.50].
baretailed calls [$0.50].
boccirock calls [$0.50].
Calvin494949 raises [$1].
MrMiggle folds.
BigSach12 calls [$0.50].
Oldweasel calls [$0.50].
Hero raises [$1].
baretailed calls [$1].
boccirock folds.
Calvin494949 is all-In [$1]
BigSach12 calls [$1].
Oldweasel calls [$1].
Hero calls [$0.50].
baretailed calls [$0.50].

** Dealing Turn **
baretailed checks.
BigSach12 bets [$1].
Oldweasel calls [$1].
Hero raises [$2].
baretailed folds.
BigSach12 calls [$1].
Oldweasel calls [$1].

** Dealing River **
BigSach12 checks.
Oldweasel checks.
Hero bets [$1].
BigSach12 calls [$1].
Oldweasel calls [$1].
Hero shows a straight, eight to queen.
Calvin494949 shows three of a kind, nines.
Calvin494949 shows 8,7,6,4,2 for low.
BigSach12 shows high card ace.
BigSach12 shows 8,7,6,2,A for low.
Oldweasel shows a pair of jacks.
Oldweasel shows 8,7,6,2,A for low.
Hero wins $4.38 from side pot #1 with a straight, eight to queen.
BigSach12 wins Lo ($2.19) from side pot #1 with 8,7,6,2,A.
Oldweasel wins Lo ($2.18) from side pot #1 with 8,7,6,2,A.
Hero wins $6.75 from the main pot with a straight, eight to queen.
BigSach12 wins Lo ($3.38) from the main pot with 8,7,6,2,A.
Oldweasel wins Lo ($3.37) from the main pot with 8,7,6,2,A.


Since only the shortstack shows aggression on the flop I figure that if ANYONE has the nut flush draw it is him, so I decide to put him in so I can build a side pot if I hit. I'm also thinking that since I'm holding 4 spades my straight should hold up very often if it does hit. Am I being an overaggressive card catching muppet here? I tried to apply some "Advanced Concepts(tm)"...

[JDLush]

I like the play, you have a big wrap, but probably the last thing you want to see here is a spade, you are rooting to hit your straight more than the flush.

Of course, that hand is a preflop fold most of the time regardless. You don't want to get in the habit of drawing to non nut flushes when you have 2 fewer outs than normal.

[briachek]

i kinda like it. You have a good draw (don't discount someone else other than the shortie with the nut flush draw) and getting so many people trapped in the hand isn't bad. Get that money in.

[Felonius_Monk]